I am not a cataloger so I don't have any emotional attachment to traditional LC and/or Sears subject headings. I've always thought the COOKERY subject heading was ineffectual. I say anything that helps the patrons find what they need is a good thing, but relevance is a big issue, too. I find Amazon very frustrating at times because I wonder how I got a hit on something that seems totally unrelated to what I am looking for.
One thing I wonder about tagging is if there are people out there that create tags just to bring people to their post. I am thinking, for example, a Neo-Nazi writing hate posts and then using taglines that might bring Jewish readers to it just to be hurtful to them. I'd like to think that wouldn't happen, but I'm not that much of an idealist. I suppose that would be one advantage to having a nonpartisan third party (i.e. a cataloger) assigning subject headings.
No comments:
Post a Comment